E - 鉄道旅行 / Railway Trip Editorial by admin Editorial for printing
Claude Opus 5 (High)Overview
In this problem, we are given an undirected graph where each edge offers two options of (fare, travel time). We want to find the minimum time to travel from city \(1\) to city \(N\) while keeping the total fare at or below \(K\) yen. This can be solved using Dijkstra’s algorithm where the state is defined as a pair of (current city, amount of money spent) (often called extended or state-space Dijkstra).
Analysis
Observation 1: Double the fare since there are two people
Using the \(i\)-th railway line with a local train costs \(2A_i\) yen, and using an express train costs \(2B_i\) yen. If we treat \(2A_i\) and \(2B_i\) as the edge costs from the beginning, we can ignore the fact that there are two people and treat the problem as if it were for a single person.
Observation 2: Standard Dijkstra is not sufficient
If there were no budget constraint, we could simply set the weight of each edge to \(\min(S_i, T_i)\) and run standard Dijkstra. However, because of the budget constraint, there is a trade-off:
- Choosing a faster but more expensive train may leave you with insufficient money for subsequent segments.
- Conversely, choosing a cheaper but slower train may allow you to spend more later, resulting in a faster overall travel time.
Therefore, knowing only “the shortest time to reach city \(v\)” is insufficient to describe the state. Even when arriving at the same city \(v\), whether it is better to have “spent 300 yen to arrive in 10 minutes” or “spent 100 yen to arrive in 50 minutes” depends on the remaining journey.
Observation 3: Include the amount spent in the state
Thus, we define the state as:
\[\text{dist}[v][c] = \text{minimum time required to reach city } v \text{ having spent a total of } c \text{ yen}\]
Since \(K \le 1000\) is small, there are only \(K+1\) possible values for \(c\), from \(0\) to \(K\). The number of states is \(N \times (K+1) \le 200 \times 1001 \approx 2 \times 10^5\), which is small enough to run well within the time limit.
In this state space, edges become transitions with non-negative weights (= times): $\((v, c) \xrightarrow{\ S_i \ } (u, c + 2A_i), \qquad (v, c) \xrightarrow{\ T_i \ } (u, c + 2B_i)\)$ Thus, standard Dijkstra’s algorithm can be applied directly.
Although the problem statement mentions that “you may visit the same city or use the same railway line any number of times,” the total amount of money spent is strictly non-decreasing, so states cannot loop infinitely to become cheaper or faster. It can be treated straightforwardly as a shortest path problem.
Algorithm
- Read the input. For each railway line \(i\), add the following undirected edges in both directions:
- An edge with cost \(2A_i\) and time \(S_i\)
- An edge with cost \(2B_i\) and time \(T_i\) (Edges with cost strictly greater than \(K\) can never be used, so they can be discarded immediately).
- Initialize
dist[v][c]with \(\infty\), setdist[1][0] = 0, and push \((0, 1, 0)\) into the priority queue. - Pop the state \((d, u, c)\) with the minimum time from the queue. If
d != dist[u][c], this is an outdated entry, so skip it (lazy deletion). - For each edge outgoing from \(u\), if the new total cost \(nc = c + \text{cost}\) exceeds \(K\), skip it. Otherwise, if
dist[to][nc]can be updated with \(nd = d + \text{time}\), update it and push \((nd, \text{to}, nc)\) into the queue. - Finally, the answer is \(\min_{0 \le c \le K} \text{dist}[N][c]\). If this remains \(\infty\), output
-1.
Concrete Example
Suppose there is a railway line connecting cities \(1\) and \(2\) offering “local train with \(A=1\) (2 yen for two people) taking 100 minutes” and “express train with \(B=400\) (800 yen for two people) taking 1 minute.” If \(K = 500\), the express train edge (800 yen) is not created in the first place, and only \((1,0) \to (2,2)\) taking 100 minutes is created. If \(K = 1000\), \((1,0) \to (2,800)\) taking 1 minute is created, and this one will be chosen.
Complexity
The number of states is \(V' = N(K+1)\), and the number of state transitions (edges) is \(E' = 4M(K+1)\) (2 options per line \(\times\) bidirectional \(\times\) each possible cost).
- Time Complexity: \(O\big((N K + M K)\log (N K)\big)\) — this is very fast, with at most around \(500 \cdot 1001 \cdot 4 \approx 2\times10^6\) transitions multiplied by a \(\log\) factor.
- Space Complexity: \(O(NK + M)\)
Implementation Points
Do not forget to double the fares: The fares are given “per person”, so use \(2A_i\) and \(2B_i\) (as a result, the total money spent will always be an even number).
Watch out for overflow: Since \(S_i, T_i \le 10^9\) and a path can traverse up to roughly \(K/2 = 500\) edges, the total time can reach around \(5\times10^{11}\). Use a 64-bit integer (
long long) instead ofint. It is also safe to setINFto a value that does not overflow when added to (e.g.,LLONG_MAX/4).Do not add edges with cost \(> K\): This keeps the graph smaller and adds a layer of safety alongside the
nc > Ktransition check.The answer is the minimum over all \(c\): You do not have to spend exactly \(K\) yen, so minimize \(\text{dist}[N][c]\) over \(c = 0 \ldots K\).
Multiple edges and self-loops: Multiple railway lines may connect the same pair of cities, so representing the graph with an adjacency list rather than an adjacency matrix is the standard approach.
Unreachability can be checked with
ans >= INF, in which case output-1.Source Code
#include <bits/stdc++.h>
using namespace std;
int main(){
int N, M, K;
if(!(cin >> N >> M >> K)) return 0;
struct E { int to; int cost; long long time; };
vector<vector<E>> g(N+1);
for(int i=0;i<M;i++){
int u,v; long long a,b,s,t;
cin >> u >> v >> a >> b >> s >> t;
long long ca = 2*a, cb = 2*b;
if(ca <= K){
g[u].push_back({v,(int)ca,s});
g[v].push_back({u,(int)ca,s});
}
if(cb <= K){
g[u].push_back({v,(int)cb,t});
g[v].push_back({u,(int)cb,t});
}
}
const long long INF = LLONG_MAX/4;
// dist[node][spent]
vector<vector<long long>> dist(N+1, vector<long long>(K+1, INF));
using P = tuple<long long,int,int>;
priority_queue<P, vector<P>, greater<P>> pq;
dist[1][0] = 0;
pq.push({0,1,0});
while(!pq.empty()){
auto [d,u,c] = pq.top(); pq.pop();
if(d != dist[u][c]) continue;
for(const auto &e : g[u]){
int nc = c + e.cost;
if(nc > K) continue;
long long nd = d + e.time;
if(nd < dist[e.to][nc]){
dist[e.to][nc] = nd;
pq.push({nd, e.to, nc});
}
}
}
long long ans = INF;
for(int c=0;c<=K;c++) ans = min(ans, dist[N][c]);
if(ans >= INF) cout << -1 << "\n";
else cout << ans << "\n";
return 0;
}
This editorial was generated by claude5opus-high.
posted:
last update: