Official

D - 警備員の配置 / Placement of Security Guards Editorial by admin

Claude 4.6 Opus (Thinking)

Overview

This is an Interval Covering Problem where we need to select the minimum number of given intervals (guard candidates) to cover all \(N\) sections arranged in a line.

Analysis

Key Insight

This problem is a classic greedy algorithm problem: “When completely covering the interval \([1, N]\) on the number line using multiple given intervals, what is the minimum number of intervals required?”

Issues with the Naive Approach

Exhaustively searching all possible selections of guards yields \(2^M\) combinations, and since \(M\) can be up to \(2 \times 10^5\), this is far too slow.

Solution Using Greedy Algorithm

For the interval covering problem, the following greedy strategy is known to yield an optimal solution:

Among the intervals that can cover the leftmost position not yet covered, choose the one with the largest right endpoint.

Let’s consider a concrete example. With \(N = 10\) and intervals \([1,3], [2,6], [4,8], [7,10]\):

  1. First, covered = \(0\). We want to cover position \(1\) → Intervals with \(L \leq 1\) are \([1,3]\) and \([2,6]\) (\([2,6]\) has \(L=2 > 1\), so it’s not eligible). Choose \([1,3]\), covered = \(3\).
  2. We want to cover position \(4\) → Among intervals with \(L \leq 4\), the one with maximum \(R\) is \([4,8]\) (\(R=8\)) and \([2,6]\) (\(R=6\)). Choose \([4,8]\), covered = \(8\).
  3. We want to cover position \(9\) → Among intervals with \(L \leq 9\), choose \([7,10]\) (\(R=10\)), covered = \(10\).

The answer is \(3\) guards.

Algorithm

  1. Sort the intervals in ascending order of left endpoint \(L_i\).
  2. Prepare a variable covered (the right endpoint of the covered range, initially \(0\)) and a pointer i for scanning the intervals.
  3. While covered < N, repeat the following:
    • The next position to cover is covered + 1.
    • Sequentially examine intervals satisfying \(L \leq\) covered + 1, and record the one with the maximum \(R\) as best.
    • If no best is found (or best \(\leq\) covered), covering is impossible, so output \(-1\).
    • Otherwise, set covered = best and increment the number of selected guards by \(1\).
  4. After the loop ends, output the number of selected guards.

Key Point: Since we scan the sorted intervals from front to back, the pointer i never goes backward, and each interval is examined at most once overall.

Complexity

  • Time complexity: \(O(M \log M)\) (dominated by sorting; the greedy loop itself is \(O(M)\))
  • Space complexity: \(O(M)\) (array to store the intervals)

Although \(N\) can be as large as \(10^9\), this is not a problem because the loop depends on the number of intervals \(M\).

Implementation Notes

  • covered means “sections \(1\) through covered are covered,” with an initial value of \(0\) (nothing is covered). The next position to cover is covered + 1.

  • By using a pointer i after sorting to scan the intervals only once (a two-pointer-like technique), the entire loop is kept to \(O(M)\).

  • If coverage cannot be extended (best == -1 or best <= covered), it is determined to be impossible and \(-1\) is returned early.

    Source Code

import sys

def solve():
    input_data = sys.stdin.buffer.read().split()
    idx = 0
    N = int(input_data[idx]); idx += 1
    M = int(input_data[idx]); idx += 1
    
    intervals = []
    for i in range(M):
        L = int(input_data[idx]); idx += 1
        R = int(input_data[idx]); idx += 1
        intervals.append((L, R))
    
    # Greedy interval covering
    # Sort by left endpoint
    intervals.sort()
    
    count = 0
    covered = 0  # we have covered up to 'covered' (0 means nothing covered yet)
    i = 0
    
    while covered < N:
        # We need to cover position covered+1
        # Find the interval with L <= covered+1 that has the maximum R
        best = -1
        while i < M and intervals[i][0] <= covered + 1:
            if intervals[i][1] > best:
                best = intervals[i][1]
            i += 1
        
        if best == -1 or best <= covered:
            # Can't extend coverage
            print(-1)
            return
        
        covered = best
        count += 1
    
    print(count)

solve()

This editorial was generated by claude4.6opus-thinking.

posted:
last update: